bjmdds wrote:We need a 10 year moratorium on legal immigration and a zero tolerance on illegal immigration here. We owe $18 trillion. We cannot afford to allow anyone else in here, and give them goodies citizens here do not even get who work. Let your country take them all if you like. The shortage of jobs here and the overinflux of illegals is wrecking the economy here. People who came here a century ago did not have to be watched by the USA government because they did not come here to destroy it, like a lot who are here now plot to do damage. Desperate times require desperate measures.
You won't be surprised that I'm going to argue with you on this, but contrary to what you might think, it's not for purely self-interested reasons. I have since moved back to the UK, as you know, and my wife and I have both agreed that if we had our time over again, she would have moved here in 2003 instead of me moving there. A total ban on immigration would have actually stopped us making a mistake. However, the personal circumstances of one couple are no basis for public policy, so I still think you're wrong, for a couple of reasons.
American jobs: People don't have to come to America for good jobs any more, the well-paying jobs are coming to them. Remember that guy you supported in the 2008 election who made his fortune (or at least the part of it he didn't inherit) doing just that? Yes, there are still people coming to America for work reasons. I'd estimate that the British expats group I was a member of in Columbia was pretty much evenly divided between them and people like myself who came for reasons of love and marriage. However, the people who came for jobs were usually only intending to stay for a few years and then move back. The only reason the company went to the trouble and expense of bringing them over is that they couldn't fill the position locally - hardly surprising as we were in South Carolina. What are they supposed to do, give a science and technology job to one of the local yokels who, to steal a line from Tina Fey, believes that Adam and Eve rode dinosaurs to church?
Terrorism: of course America needs to protect her borders, but a total immigration ban for 10 years (Why 10 years? Is the terrorist threat going to disappear after that?) is way beyond what is needed to achieve that. It's like trying to abolish murder by not only banning guns, but only allowing people to use plastic cutlery and write with crayons, so that no-one has access to anything that could conceivably be used as a murder weapon. I find it interesting that no presidential candidate is proposing such a total immigration ban, even in the early stages of the Republican primary, which are often a competition to see who can say the craziest things in order to appease the Tea Party base. It suggests that there's no real support for it anywhere.
I do agree with you about getting tough on illegal immigration, though. I jumped through hoops to get my green card, why shouldn't they? I can understand it in cases where people are fleeing war and disaster, but even then, there are proper channels. I partly wrote
Jhaakob Comes to Earth in order to help refugees and asylum seekers understand the legal process, the one you want to abolish.